Sicily Coal Fired Pizza: Experience Authentic Italian Flavors in Middletown, CT

1st time visit, celebrating my birthday. I can't say enough about Sicily's. From the awesome staff, and amazing food. My waiter went above and beyond. Everything was top notch. I bragged about the restaurant for days. Thank you all so much, my family and I really loved it and made my birthday the best. Highly recommend and We will definitely be back.

Octopus as a starter with the yuca fries and pomegranates was a delicious combination. We shared the Maine Lobster Gnocchi and it was so tasty! The portion was huge but I won’t complain about leftovers. Definitely will be back to try something else next time.

The food was absolutely delicious, fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. Every bite felt like a taste of authentic Italy. The bartenders were phenomenal; friendly, attentive, and made great recommendations. The sangrias could be a little better, but it didn’t take away from the overall experience. You can tell they really care about creating a welcoming atmosphere. Definitely a spot I’ll be coming back to!

This is my second time coming to Sicily. The first time I got a mashed potato pie. It was excellent. Today I got a chicken and bacon pizza. I wanted to try one with sauce. It was phenomenal. Not my #1 place, bit damn good. They can definitely hang with New Haven places. The wife got a short rib dinner. She said is was excellent. My only gripe is that I dont live close enough to go more often. Will definitely be back. I forget our waiters name. But he was great too.

Our family of six, ages 8-55, ate dinner at Sicily Coal Fired Pizza. We had a great time and enjoyed the lively, modern atmosphere. What impressed us the most was the EXCEPTIONAL service. It was the best service we've had the pleasure of experiencing in quite some time. Our primary server, Mars, was sweet, professional, and genuine. We never had to wait for drink refills, extra bread and butter, etc, and she was on point with a few additional menu/food requests. The other wait staff members were great as well. Our dishes were cleared promptly, and we were checked on frequently without being intrusive. Where our experience fell short a bit was the actual meal. Although we appreciated the quality and quantity of the food, it did not seem to warrant the pricing. The homemade pasta had a nice texture, but the vodka sauce was lackluster. I was personally disappointed with the Not Your Tradition’ Bolognese. The "seasonal" spices were a turn-off for me. Mars asked immediately if she could replace my meal. The Mozzarella, Ricotta, & Prosciutto di Parma Stuffed Grilled Chicken Breast was decent, but not a favorite. We did enjoy the bread, sweet chili wings, garlic bread, and drinks. My son loved the house lager on tap. The Gnocchi La Sicily with an additional meatball was excellent. My youngest son rated the pepperoni pizza a 4.5/5. He gave the bread a resounding 5/5! We will definitely be back, especially now that we have a better feel for the menu. Again, I cannot stress how amazing the service was which is hard to find these days.

We went here to get a coal fired pizza for dinner tonight. We ended up getting the Buffalo Wings too. Both were very good in portions and in regard to flavor/taste. The service here was great. We were seated quickly and everyone we interacted with was very friendly. The place was clean. We parked in the parking lot in the back and found a great parking space, that was conveniently located near the rear entrance. We were seated near the area where the pizzas are made and I can tell you that the gentlemen making the pies were very busy and were working like a well-oiled machine. We will definitely be coming back in the future as we noticed many other great looking items coming out from the back, including, but not limited to these crazy big, side mounted pretzels… It’s not my thing, but I noticed the menu had both vegetarian and vegan food options available. The area is great. There are lots of shops and places to check out, even in the evening.

We came here to celebrate a friend’s birthday and had such a wonderful experience! Our waitress was incredibly personable and attentive, making the evening feel extra special. The pizza was excellent with so many unique options to choose from, and the salad was fresh and delicious — the balsamic dressing was absolutely incredible. The atmosphere is beautiful and inviting, and having a live piano player made it even more memorable. We’ll definitely be back!

Great food, good selections on menu. We didnt have the pizza but did see a couplw that others were eating. They looked good too!